Wednesday, January 6, 2016

Review - - Listen to the Moon

Listen to the Moon
By Rose Lerner
Publisher: Samhain
Release Date: January 5, 2016

John Toogood is a man who likes his work, and he is on his way to seeing his ambition fulfilled when the choices someone else makes leaves John without a job. It isn’t that John thinks Nick Dymond was wrong to marry Phoebe Sparks (Sweet Disorder); it’s just that John was unprepared for the effect of that decision on him. He accepted the position as valet to Nick at the request of the Countess of Tassell, Nick’s mother, expecting to return to the service of Nick’s older brother Stephen, Lord Lenfield, whose political ambitions offered more scope for a skilled valet. John did not expect the countess’s displeasure over Nick’s marriage to lead her to blacklist him among men within her circle of influence. Since Nick can no longer afford to pay a valet’s salary, John is jobless. Needing a place to stay, he rents the rooms formerly occupied by the newly married Phoebe Dymond, despite the fact that he finds disturbing his awareness of Sukey Grimes, the audacious maid who cleans the rooms—and not very efficiently in John’s opinion.

Sukey Grimes (and I feel certain Lerner intended readers to chuckle at that name for a character who cleans haphazardly) and John have little in common. Their attitude toward their work is different, their upbringing was different, their status in servants’ hierarchy is different, and there is an eighteen-year age difference between forty-year-old John and the younger maid. Sukey’s philosophy is that one should do just enough work to get paid. She wants to make enough money to support herself, maintain her independence, and prove wrong her mother’s prediction that Sukey will end up in the workhouse. She is amused by John and just as aware of his attractions as he is of hers. Regardless of the mutual attraction, John fears taking advantage of Sukey, and their early relationship can be described as a flirtatious friendship with an adversarial edge. But circumstances change. When John is offered a job as butler in a vicar’s household contingent upon his being a married man, he asks Sukey to be his wife and part of his staff. Sukey is not in love with John, and she is not interested in marriage to anyone. She has a very negative view of the institution. But when she needs a job, John’s proposition becomes more appealing. Can these two very different people make a success of their new jobs and their new marriage?

Regulars at the Dish know that I’m a huge Rose Lerner fan and have been since her first book. Each of her books has given me something new to rave about. I love the way this third book in the Lively St. Lemeston series takes established romance tropes and gives them not exactly a twist bur rather applies them in a new situation. The marriage of convenience is one of the oldest and best loved tropes. I must have read thousands of romances that use it, but this is the first time the marriage of convenience has been between a valet turned butler and a maid. I also consider this a cross-class romance. Lerner makes her readers aware that the servants’ world is no less hierarchically structured than is that of their employers. If you have read many Regency/ Victorian romances, you have doubtless been told this. The difference here is that Lerner shows us the differences in a valet, a butler, and a maid. To cite just one small detail--when John and Sukey first meet, he gives her his card: “He pulled a card out of his pocket. John Toogood, it read. Gentleman’s Gentleman. His own card! Upper servants were another species, right enough.”

Lerner also uses her impressive research skills and commitment to historical accuracy to give her readers not a backdrop but a world—a world very different from the usual one of ballrooms, house parties, curricle races, and gentlemen’s clubs but no less dimensional and detailed for all its differences.

Finally, I applaud the way Lerner handles the substantial age difference. It is neither ignored nor exaggerated. It is handled with a degree of realism that I don’t remember encountering in another historical. There is something of the father-daughter dynamic in John and Sukey’s relationship. He comes across as paternalistic at points, and she behaves like a child at times. John feels a particular responsibility:

She's been lonely and afraid, young and inexperienced, and he'd used it to talk her into a marriage that she'd turned down when she had a job.

The more he wanted her, the more he needed her, the more he asked her for - the less chance she would have to be the woman she'd wanted to be, who stood on her own two feet, who had nothing between her and the sun. The less chance she'd have to discover what she really wanted. He'd been collecting his burdens for forty years. Even if they'd grown heavy for him, she was too young to be asked to shoulder half.                      

Lerner minimizes neither the personal nor the job-related obstacles in their relationship. Love is messy and difficult and challenging as often as it is exhilarating and comforting, and transcendent. This story recognizes that truth.

If you like romances that are unconventional, if you like to see a relationship develop as the H/H change and grow, if you are a Downton Abbey fan, or if you just long to read a story that pulls you into its world, add Listen to the Moon to your TBR immediately.  I highly recommend it.



  1. Like you, Janga, I'm a huge fan of Rose Lerner's books. I'm just starting Listen to the Moon!

  2. have not read any Rose Lerner books. Going to go 1 click this one.

  3. I loved In For a Penny. I've got a couple more of hers on my kindle. I need to catch up!

  4. I am so looking forward to reading this book!