Friday, February 20, 2026

Review - - Falling for the Rabbi

Falling for the Rabbi
by Jennifer Wilck
Matchmaker, Matchmaker - Book 1
Publisher: Harlequin
Release Date: February 24, 2026
Reviewed by Hellie 
 



 Josh Axelrod is incensed! His matchmaker date brought along her annoying best friend—Emma something-or-other. The same Emma who’s ruining the house filled with the young rabbi’s childhood memories and turning it into a bookstore. Sure, she captures his attention but—no. Just no. Emma is too impulsive. Too out there. And he’s a Rabbi, for God’s sake! Except now, it seems impossible to avoid her. And with every encounter, “no” feels more like “yes.” Perhaps the unwitting Josh and Emma were always the match meant to be… 

 



Hellie’s Heeds

 

I always marvel at Harlequin stories because the writing has to be so tight, but I feel Jennifer Wilck is even more exceptional because while I know the writing is tight, it also feels luxurious as I’m getting so much detail and setting and character development with just a few sentences or pages. I also adore opposites attract motifs and this one has it in spades. Josh feels like Mr. Type A. He has a plan–and if that plan derails (say by a beloved grandmother or a feisty bookstore owner), he handles everything poorly. Emma, on the other hand, can never do anything right. That’s been the story of her life from her parents who constantly compare her to her sister, and not favorably. It’s no surprise to the reader when Emma will do anything for her best friend, Samantha, who has been with her through it all, but what happens when her best friend is matched with someone that Emma is attracted to? And worse, that someone is the grandson of the woman who sold her the house where Emma is putting her bookstore–and he hates her? Oh, so much conflict–and we haven’t gotten to chapter 3 yet. 

 

The author does an impeccable job of building the relationship between the two, despite the fact they have so many reasons not to be together–in the end, it feels inevitable. And the conflict, which seems to come from many different and legitimate angles (her parents, her best friend, Emma’s guilt that she’s “stolen” love interests of Sam before) does keep the story moving swiftly. However Sam’s definition of “man stealing” is a bit much considering both incidents occurred prior to adulthood and that Sam doesn’t give any blame to the men in the situation (since Emma was not actively seeking their attention.) It felt immature, but it also became clear this is a character growth issue for Sam, due to her childhood and issues she still needs to wrestle with. It will be interesting to see how this is handled in future books. 

 

The conflict that was the black moment of sorts for Emma and Josh seemed abrupt; and frankly I was on Emma’s side about it. But I will respect that the issue was real for Josh. For me that probably felt the weakest part of the story, but I admit that is probably a “me-issue.” Other readers may totally be with Josh here. I’ll let the reader decide. 

 

If you love the idea of a smaller town near the bustle of New York City where you can attend a Winter Festival and ride around in a sleigh and drink hot cocoa and a community where the local senior assisted living is made up by a group of octogenarians who could give partying tips to the local fraternities, you will likely enjoy this small town and its community. I know I did. I can’t wait for the next book in the series!

 


No comments:

Post a Comment